mtg cards with buyback Best in (2026) — Top Picks for Commander & Beyond Can I reduce the cost

The best part is that the loyalty counter ability triggers on combat damage, not just damage to a player

This card may whiff if the only creature found is a costly beater that can't be cast earlier in the game

Or you can discard a card and draw, so she's card flow, ramping, or making a Role for pumping your team or her

Spell Stutter can be a better effect, but it requires faeries, whereas this card is usually a four-of in decks that need both lessons and counterspells

Note that colorless topdeck manipulation like Scroll Rack and Sensei's Divining Top help to get the most from Cait Sith

This will likely make the deck better and faster at closing games once you get the lead